OK. You asked for it (and if you didn't, and don't want to hear about it or have to think about it, then go ahead and skip this post. My neighbor who I walk with has already told me that I've now made her totally paranoid about her "lack of concern"--her words, not mine-- with her kids education, which is not what I want to do to anyone. And I know I have a lot of friends who are teachers, so please, do not think I'm attacking all teachers, and a lot of what I feel is actually more about the administration and the government, not the individual teachers, anyway.)
I could probably write a post on each of the following ideas, but for now I'm going to try to just throw my ideas out there in a semi-concise manner. So, first of all, the background that got me thinking about schools:
1) I was a good student, but always maintained that I did not need to spend 6 hours a day in the classroom to learn what we learned each day. In elementary school, I spent a lot of time doing extra-credit puzzles and games, reading with my book under my desk when I was supposed to be working on other things, and trying to finish all my homework before school let out for the day (the challenge of a race against the clock made it exciting--probably why my handwriting grades were attrocious). In Jr. high and high school, I took quite a few "mental health days" (I didn't know that was what they were called back then) and still stayed caught up--in fact, if I was feeling overwhelmed by the amount of homework or assignments, the easiest way to catch up was to stay home because I could work a lot faster without the teacher talking in the background. And when I was in class, I was often writing. Not for school, but writing the stories that I had running through my head all the time. Which is why. . .
2) School doesn't let you study everything that you are intersted in. I was VERY interested in creative writing, but I didn't get to take a class that focused on that until my sophomore year of college. And who's decided that essay writing is more important than creative writing (not that we didn't do any of it in school, but I would have loved to have year long classes that could have helped learn to develop my characters and plot more than I figured out doing it all by myself for years).
3) Full day kindergarten--only option here in Charlotte and I'm not a fan. Add in the bus time, and for our neighborhood school, the kids are gone from 8:30 to 3:45 every day. That leaves only 4 hours each night for snack, homework, dinner, bath, bedtime ritual, any music, dance, or sports, oh, and we should have some family time in there, too.
4) Homework--not a fan of that either. I was one of the good kids who usually did mine, but just because I liked getting A's, not because I was learning anything from a lot of it. Daddy-o never was a fan, so he didn't take any convincing here.
5) Grades--Like I said, I liked getting A's and was a very good student, all the way through college. But I don't think I learned near as much as I could have and should have. Because I was one of those kids who would ask, "Is this going to be on the test," and if not, I stopped listening (novels were the one exception. I had an English teacher in HS who would just forget to finish assigning the chapters in whatever book we were reading at the time and I could never understand the kids who didn't want to find out what happened and would just not ever finish the book.) I knew what I needed to do to get an A and that was what I did. Sometimes, I decided a B was good enough and so I just did that amount. Not really the ideal "education".
6) Outdoor time--I love being outside. I think I just wake up when I'm in nature--all my senses work a little better, my brain is more aware and makes connections a little faster. And schools give kids less and less time outside. Less recess, less PE, less field trips. They just don't have time.
7) Creativity--The other thing that schools don't have a lot of time for is creativity. It depends on the teacher, to some degree, but the government has put so many standards that have to be taught at each grade that there isn't always much room to be flexible and to let the kids have time to create. And I have a very creative daughter. I love to see what she will make out of the "junk" that they supply at her preschool--electronics, buttons, old cards, blocks of wood, boxes, sparkly bits and peices. It all comes together to make sculptures. Or she'll paint, one day its abstact art because she was playing with mixing red and blue, the next day she's made a map of a garden, or a portrait of her best friend. In her preschool, they don't have to cut on the line, color in the lines, or make something just like the sample. And they can make several things one day, and none another, if that's what they feel like. I'm not ready for her to have that taken away.
Those are the basics as to why I started reading and looking into our school options. I've read about how kids actually want to learn; how they will remember the things they discover on their own and are passionate about, unlike the facts they memorize for a test; how there really isn't any research that proves homework has any value until at least 10th grade and lots of reasons why it is harmful; how competition in the classroom isn't fostering learning and teaches kids all types of things about social heirarchy that may not really be what we want our kids to learn; and how just because someone has decided that reading, writing, and arithmetic are important, why does that have to mean they are MORE important than art, music, science, nature, physical activity, learning to serve others, and how to be an all-around happy, productive person. I've just started realizing over the years that the education system that we take as matter-of-fact isn't the only way to do it and its made me think about what is most important in my mind that my kids take from being "educated". And I think the biggest thing to me is that they love to learn, whatever it is.
I'll admit that the full-day kindergarten alone was a pretty big concern. But we did look into a local charter school--one where they have a low student to teacher ration, no grades, no homework in the lower grades and only meaningful homework after that (which means they don't get a packet of things on Monday to finish by the end of the week, but might continue a project at home if it requires supplies they don't have at school, or its something that their parents need to help with, like a family history assignment.) The charter school also doesn't have rules about when they can use the bathroom or get a drink or eat, and they have lunch in their classroom, so no nazi lunch lady flashing the lights and telling them to all be silent, or teachers marching them down the hall with one hand on their hips and one hand on their lips (one of the schools here does that--to keep the kids from touching and from talking, but it makes them look like they have major attitude issues when they march around this way.)
Well, for the 38 open kindergarten spots, we were number 372 in the lottery, so its not happening this year. And kindergarten is usually your best shot because once people get in, they don't tend to drop out of this school, so there aren't a lot of openings in the other grades.
I was pretty disappointed, but at the same time, there is a little part of me that wasn't even sure about that school either because the more I've read about
unschooling (basically, an approach that assumes kids want to learn as long as we don't get in the way and ruin that natural curiousity and that they can learn in meaningful ways without textbooks and made-up lessons), the more appealing it is, especially for these younger grades.
So, we've pretty much decided to homeschool. I'm nervous about having Bean home all day, everyday. Haven't decided how to fit in my exercise (I can't run with 2 kids in the stroller--I can barely do it with Bugaboo these days), or what we'll do when she and I really need some time apart, but I do think that this will be best for her. We are actually thinking about sending her to her preschool class again next year so she can have some time to play (the other 3 kids who have birthdays after hers are all repeating, and one of them is her best friend, so she'd love it) and I can have some time with just Bugaboo. And then I wouldn't have to buy quite so many art supplies for her to play with. But we didn't find out the results of the charter school lottery until after there was already a wait list for the preschool, so we'll see if she can even get in.
That's pretty much the gist of all of it. I'm still learning and finding new resources every day. I just picked up another pile of books from the library today, and found a couple yahoo groups to join that have local resources and info for homeschoolers. I definitely want to do homeschool as a community project, not hiding away alone in our home (I don't know too many people who do it that way). We'll just see how this adventure goes.